An “Antiques Roadshow” expert refused to evaluate an item after discovering its dark history, choosing not to provide a value.
In a recent episode of the popular show “Antiques Roadshow“, an expert made headlines for refusing to place a value on a disturbing item presented to him.
The situation showed the impact of history on valuable objects and raised important questions about ethics and valuation.
Antiques Roadshow expert encountered an old item
The expert, Ronnie Archer-Morgan, was approached by a woman who brought in an ornate bracelet shaped like a ring.
At first glance, the bracelet appeared beautiful and intriguing.
The guest revealed that she had purchased it for just $3 at a house sale, unaware of its troubling past.
Many people would expect such a unique item to be worth a considerable sum, but Archer-Morgan had a different perspective.
The expert declines to value an item as soon as realizing its ‘dark’ history
He began by making it clear that he and the show do not support the trade in ivory.
“I want to make it absolutely clear that myself and we in The Antiques Roadshow wholly and unequivocally disapprove of the trade in ivory,” the expert emphasized.
The bracelet was made of ivory and had an inscription that read “Prince Jemmy of Grandy.”
This bracelet was not just a piece of jewelry; it had deep connections to the slave trade of the 17th and 18th centuries.
The expert explained that it was used to endorse the reputation of an African slave trader, with phrases like “honest fellow” inscribed on it.
As Archer-Morgan spoke, he acknowledged the bracelet’s craftsmanship but emphasized the painful history behind it.
He stated, “This is not just about the object; it’s about what it represents.”
Archer-Morgan continues: “But this ivory bangle here is not about trading in ivory, it’s about trading in human life.
“It’s probably one of the most difficult things that I’ve ever had to talk about, but talk about it we must.”
Antiques Roadshow expert expressed his discomfort in discussing the bracelet and its significance.
This was not just a matter of aesthetics; it was a reminder of human suffering and exploitation.
The expert highlighted the importance of understanding history when dealing with such items.
He noted that placing a monetary value on the bracelet would trivialize the dark past it represents.
“I just don’t want to value it,” he said. “The value lies in the lessons it can teach us.”
Reactions from the public
Archer-Morgan’s refusal to assign a price to the bracelet resonated with many viewers.
People shared their thoughts on social media, praising him for respectfully handling a difficult topic.
Some viewers found the moment both “fascinating” and “sad.” Others suggested the bracelet should be placed in a museum to tell its story.
I mean it’s part of history whether he likes it or not! A dark history yes but history nonetheless, one user said.
Personal choice if he wishes not to value it I think, the second user wrote.
So he won’t appraise this but is fine with the blood diamonds and gold coming out of Africa?
I find it odd how people put so much emphasis on slavery of the 1800s and completely disregard the slavery of today, the third user said.
Glad he mentioned the horrific torture suffered by the animal it came from too, another commented.
@arts_objects Disturbing Antiques Roadshow Item – Expert Refuses to Value !!! #antiquesroadshow #slavery #ivory #slave #antique #antiques